Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John's avatar

Edinburgh university did a big study on this back in the 1990's I think it was where they took over 2,000 cadavers and performed full autopsies on them with lots of specialists of the various body systems being involved. Only people who had died who had a good set of doctors records were considered for inclusion as the researchers wanted to be able to compare what damage they saw in the body with the drugs the people had been given down the years and to determine if the doctor's diagnosis had been correct.

The upshot of all of this research was that you had roughly a third of a chance of leaving a doctor's offiice with a correct diagnosis and a two thirds chance of leaving with an incorrect diagnosis. Similarly you had roughly a third of a chance of leaving the doctor's office with a drug that might help your condition, whether or not the diagnosis was correct, a third of a chance of leaving with a drug that probably wouldn't harm or help you, and a third of a chance of leaving with a drug that would act to make your problem worse. The situation was even worse with rare diseases where the doctor pretty much had zero chance of getting it right.

The researchers were utterly horrified at these results and so set about producing a simple database which would require the input of around fifteen to twenty answers to basic questions such as age, sex, symptoms etc and based on the data they had they reckoned that database would enable diseases, however exotic they might be, to be diagnosed with around 90% accuracy and the database would also spit out a few tests to carry out where there could be some doubt between the disease possibilities. The British NHS funded this research and many top people in the medical field were involved in the autopsies and in setting up the questions etc.

Of course when this database was then offered to doctors they point blank refused to use it because "Patients want to speak to a person not a machine!" And yet these days the first thing many doctors do is reach for Google to look up symptoms. I don't know about you but I would speak to a frog pretending to be a prince if it could diagnose me three times better than any doctor and provide me with the correct drug and not one that would actively try to kill me. Sadly the foxes are in charge of the medical henhouse in almost all Western countries.

A friend of mine had severe lung problems and she couldn't even walk the 5m from her couch to her kitchen without pausing for a breath halfway. She was on all sorts of pills and she decided to hell with this I just want to die so she stopped taking the pills and waited to die. By the end of the first week after that she was able to walk to the corner shop without pausing for breath. It was the drug interactions that were killing her. She eventually went back on the main drug but refused to take any of the others as she realised that her "doctor" had no clue how these things were interacting with one another despite him insisting that he did. She lived for years after that and it was a few years worth living compared to the state he had gotten her into and then refused to acknowledge it.

Expand full comment
Te Reagan's avatar

I’ve changed my whole lifestyle because of the medical community. They literally told me what I had was old age and that I should learn to live with it. I was 58 at that time. So, I went home even more depressed. Lucky for me I went and got a second opinion with a functional doctor.

I had two tick borne illnesses. One was attacking my white blood cells, and depleting my red. The other was cousin to Lyme disease. This doctor has since passed away of some mysterious progressive disease. They trashed this doctor on his way out. So sad.

I’m staying away from the doctors and trying to heal myself. Down 80 pounds, and started carnivore diet five days ago. Not to lose weight. I’ve already lost and am under my goal weight. I had an IBS flare up and I hear that this way of eating cures the IBS.

I’m terrified of the medical community and I do not trust them.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts